Evangelicalism’s Slow Suicide

On the recent Elisabeth Elliot saga:

Many inside observers (not outside critics) have been asking about the spiritual health of evangelicalism – especially in America. Whether it be scandals and moral breakdowns, embracing secular woke agenda items, or losing its sense of original calling, theology and beliefs, there are many problems with evangelicals in the US at the moment.

Not all of course, and most rank and file evangelicals are doing a great job of being true to their Lord and true to the gospel. But it seems that various evangelical institutions are losing their way. I have written about this often. It can include key evangelical colleges such as Wheaton in Chicago, where I graduated from some decades ago: https://billmuehlenberg.com/2015/12/19/20463/

Or it can involve a terrific seminary like Trinity Evangelical Divinity School (also in Chicago) coming to an end: https://billmuehlenberg.com/2025/04/13/on-american-evangelical-seminaries-and-theologians-my-story/

This piece is about the clash of two evangelical icons. I mentioned one in my subtitle, Elisabeth Elliot (1926-2015), the incredible Christian speaker and author, and wife of martyred missionary Jim Elliot: https://billmuehlenberg.com/2015/06/16/notable-christians-elisabeth-elliot/

The other is the flagship evangelical magazine, Christianity Today which was started in 1956 by Billy Graham. Sadly it too has been losing its way for quite some time now. I have written much on its decline as well, as in this piece: https://billmuehlenberg.com/2025/10/03/evangelical-mission-drift/  

Sadly they are starting to hit rock bottom, with a recent scandalous article claiming that Elliot may have been bisexual – I kid you not! I only just found out about this via a new piece by Carl R. Trueman in First Things titled “Does Evangelicalism Exist?”. The opening paragraph discloses what this is all about:

The controversial publication, withdrawal, and then republication by Christianity Today of an article suggesting Elisabeth Elliot was bisexual, amid a wave of layoffs and resignations that has stripped the evangelical magazine of half of its staff, has raised numerous legitimate questions about its attitude to journalism, the wisdom of its editorial policy, and its future. I don’t subscribe to it and have rarely read it, so I have no personal interest in the debacle, although the feckless strategy after the controversy broke would seem to confirm the best way to handle media storms: Never apologize, never explain, to paraphrase an adage favored by the late Duke of Edinburgh. 

Two articles by Denny Burk and Glenn T. Stanton go into all the shocking details about the accusations and charges being made in some detail. More on their two pieces in a moment. But I return to Trueman and what he had to say about the demise of evangelicalism. He continues:

The chaos also raises an important, though rarely asked, question: Does evangelicalism really exist? Certainly it exists as a whipping boy for critics who treat the sins of any one evangelical organization as the sins of all. It also gives others a platform: With no formal leadership, evangelicalism can be claimed by anyone with a social media account. But does it exist as anything more than a label?… 

 

To return to Christianity Today: The problem with organizations and institutions that claim the title “evangelical” is that they always become arenas of conflict for the disparate groups that consider themselves normative for evangelicalism and thus entitled to speak for others who claim the name. Yes, denominations are subject to similar struggles. But denominations have formal structures and established procedures for handling such battles, while magazines, conferences, and even seminaries do not. Their battles are typically fought between opponents who each think they own the institution, with no mechanisms for resolving their disputes. Informal battles, often funneled through anarchic social media engagements, thus ensue. Seen in this light, the recent chaos at Christianity Today is a practical example of the problems that arise when the word evangelicalism is reified, ceasing to be a loosely descriptive term and becoming something prescriptive. Everyone piles on, even those who can barely hide their glee behind their rhetoric of outrage. https://firstthings.com/does-evangelicalism-exist/

As to the actual story, let me share from the two other writers already mentioned. Stanton’s article is titled “‘Christianity Today’ Goes Tabloid; Insinuates Elisabeth Elliot Was Bisexual”. He writes:

The article was published last week, then pulled because it had not been properly vetted by executives. It was then subsequently reviewed and republished on October 16, insinuating Elliot had a sexual relationship with the late Virginia Mollenkott, a lesbian-identified feminist scholar on the fringes of evangelicalism who, later in life, considered herself “bigender.”

 

CT, a once great magazine founded in 1956 by the late, great Billy Graham, made this charge on a single, unconfirmed accusation by a gay advocate “historian” William Stell who is promoting his new book, Born Again Queer: The History of Gay Activism and the Making of Antigay Christianity. (Truth is Christianity turned “antigay” when Jesus uttered the texts of Mark 10:6-8 and Matthew 19:4-6.) 

 

Stell bases his conclusion on a story Mollenkott told him in an interview for his book. There is no evidence in the CT story that Stell tried to corroborate Mollenkott’s claim with any confirming source. Mollenkott died in 2020, and Elliot passed in 2015, so neither woman can be consulted on the matter.

 

But this fact does not keep CT from instructing us, “The source material Stell has brought to light, though, should inform the church’s treatment of Christians who experience same-sex attraction, as Elliot seems likely to have experienced.” Should it really? Especially considering the only evidence CT provides is unsubstantiated hearsay?

 

The CT article was written by award-winning author Lucy S.R. Austen, who researched and penned the 2023 biography, Elisabeth Elliot: A Life. It was published by Crossway, a scripturally-faithful and exacting evangelical publisher. After writing such a beautiful biography of Elliot, Austen does nearly nothing to defend Elliot’s reputation. 

 

She appears to trade in the same salacious gossip about Elliot that Stell did in his pro-gay book. CT masks all this under the title, “What We Know – and Cannot Know – About Elisabeth’s Elliot’s Sexuality.” CT’s subtitle explains, “Historian William Stell has published an interview suggesting Elliot was bisexual. Her private papers make it plausible too.”

He finishes his piece:

Austen does note in her CT piece, “Of course, years after both women’s deaths and the events in question, we can’t know whether the conversation happened as Mollenkott described – or indeed whether it happened at all” as “[n]either woman is available for further inquiry.” They are not.

 

But that didn’t keep Austen and CT from publishing their salacious piece on nothing but innuendo. And they conclude it with two paragraphs of soft gay apologetics, explaining, “There should be nothing shocking or scandalous about the mere discovery that Elliot was attracted to women as well as men.” Austen adds, “To welcome honesty about that experience is not to approve of sin, and we can work toward a world where people aren’t forced to choose between staying in the closet and leaving the evangelical church.”

 

So, Austen spends years carefully studying and cataloguing the life of a great Christian woman and publishes her work in a wonderful book with no hint of any question of Elliot’s sexuality. But a young queer advocacy historian dredges up an unsubstantiated story and she feels free to backfill the claim for CT with no evidence of her own … only providing carefully selected innuendo.

 

You should read the CT piece for yourself and look for one piece of actual evidence provided for the claim. Note also that World magazine published a very thoughtful critique of Christianity Today’s provocative article, authored by Boyce College professor, Denny Burk. https://dailycitizen.focusonthefamily.com/christianity-today-goes-tabloid-insinuates-elisabeth-elliot-was-bisexual/

And to Burk I now turn. He says in part:

The scandal here is not Elliot. The scandal is that Austen’s article provides exactly zero evidence to support the claim that Elliot was a bisexual. Zero. None. Nada.

 

Rather, the entire case rests on a single interview with the late Mollenkott who recounted a story not of a lesbian affair with Elliot but of Mollenkott threatening to smear Elliot as a lesbian if Elliot outed Mollenkott. As even Austen admits, we don’t even know if Mollenkott’s account is true. The event she recounts happened 50 years before the interview, has not been corroborated by anyone, and both of the principals are dead (Elliot and Mollenkott). But even if it were true, there is no admission of bisexuality on Elliot’s part.

And he concludes:

Scripture is crystal clear, absolutely crystal clear. Homosexuality is classified along with murder and adultery and everything else. It’s just in that list of sins. … What would give a homosexual person who claims that he was born that way the right to be sexually active when God has made it crystal clear that the only place for sexual activity is in the marriage bed?… What gives the homosexual the right to think that he has a special dispensation to sleep with members of the same sex? God deplores it. He hates it.

 

But perhaps most disturbing of all is Austen’s own perspective concerning gay relationships. She says that there is nothing “scandalous” or wrong about Elliot’s supposed experience of same-sex attraction. According to her, Christians shouldn’t be troubled by this at all. When I asked her to comment on this, Austen responded via e-mail,

 

“My argument is that, even if it were at some future point to turn out to be confirmed that Elliot experienced attraction to the same sex, attraction is not a sin. Sin would arise from decisions of the will and action… Neither Elliot nor anyone else should be treated or viewed harshly by fellow members of the body merely because of attraction, when it is submitted to the Lordship of Christ.”

 

Of course, I don’t want to see anyone mistreated either. But I couldn’t disagree more with the theological perspective underlying these remarks. And in the aftermath of controversies about Revoice and “Side B” theology, I suspect a growing number of Bible-believing evangelicals would disagree as well.

 

In spite of Austen’s historical caveats and theological error about same-sex attraction, her article ends up giving oxygen to the idea that Elliot was a bisexual. But this claim goes far beyond anything supported by the evidence she provides. Readers would do well to leave this salacious theory behind. https://wng.org/opinions/when-journalism-crosses-a-moral-line-1792406727

Hmm, trash journalism and a rejection of the clear teachings of Scripture. How the mighty have fallen. It seems that it might be time for Christianity Today to be put out of its misery.

[1731 words]

4 Replies to “Evangelicalism’s Slow Suicide”

  1. Seems less an instance of tabloid scandal porn and more looking for an opportunity to pontificate, condescend and lecture biblically faithful Christians. The facts, of course, are incidental.

  2. In 1961 the Government Religion Evolution was introduced in Schools in Australia.
    Through the 30s – 50’s Male Youth Suicide, Property Crime and Atheism were Flatlined.
    After 8 years the SA Government introduced Abortion Legislation for the 1st time, Presumably the Australian Population had been desensitised to the fact that life existed from Conception.
    Using Acts 17 where Paul changed his approach to Greek Philosophers and used Creation. Rom 1:20 For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen…
    Creation is the Key to the Gospel.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *