The Greatest Commandment – The Most Violated Commandment

How many Christians routinely violate the greatest commandment?

If my title just spoke about the most violated commandment, many folks would think of the 10 Commandments delivered by Moses in the Old Testament, and a healthy debate might take place as to which of the ten is violated the most. That could be an interesting exercise, although I suspect that all ten would be fairly evenly broken, ignored or violated.

But by mentioning the ‘greatest commandment’ most Christians should recognise that this refers to something found in the New Testament – something spoken of by Jesus. It of course was his response when asked about what is the greatest commandment.

His reply – that it has to do with loving God with all of our being – is found in all three synoptic gospels (Matthew 22:34-40; Mark 12:28-34; Luke 10:25-28). The various component parts of the command (‘all your heart,’ ‘all your mind’ etc.) simply refer to the truth that we are to love God totally and completely, just as he has loved us totally and completely.

In offering this reply, Jesus was simply referring back to the original version of this as found in Deuteronomy 6:4-9. And the point I am seeking to make here is this: how many Christians in fact DO love God with all their mind? From my vantage point there are far too many who do not.

Before proceeding, let me point out one thing: Although the word ‘mind’ is found in the three gospel accounts, it is not found in the Deuteronomy text. But that does not mean it is not important. As J. G. McConville points out: “The phrase ‘all your heart’ might probably be rendered ‘all your mind’. The association of the [Hebrew] words leb, lebab, ‘heart’ with the intellect is clear from Jer. 5:21; Hos. 7:11).”

Once again, the point is to love God with the totality of our being – the various component parts offered simply serve to make that point. God has always sought a people who would fully love and worship him, holding nothing back. The references to the various elements simply mean that we are to love God with the entirety of our being – with all of who we are: heart, mind, soul and strength. God is to get all of us and all of our love.

I return to these biblical basics once again because there are always those who seem to delight in disobeying this commandment. Sure, they may like to come to God with all their feelings and emotions, but when it comes to loving God with their mind, many seem to baulk at this.

They simply do NOT love God with their minds. Some even try to make a virtue out of this. They have foolishly and unbiblically picked up the false notion that somehow the more unintelligent and unlearned and ignorant they are, the more spiritual they must be.

I get these folks coming to my site all the time. With a few recent pieces penned on things like philosophy and the place of reason, I have again had some fightin’ fundies come out of the woodwork, happy to attack me for daring to do so. They really seem to get angry when I dare to suggest that we actually should use our brains to glorify God.

They seem to think that the more they don’t know, the more clueless they are, and the more just plain unintelligent they are, the more they are some sort of great spiritual beings. And they are so happy to come here attacking me and others, judging us and parading their pseudo-spirituality around for all to see.

They are so unaware of how unbiblical and silly they are. They go on and on about how they trust no one, believe no one, and rely on no one – only the Word of God. But then they come along and quote other ‘mere mortals’ to justify their position!

Even more worrying is how they will come to my site – as mere men and women – telling me how wrong I am, all the while insisting that we should never listen to mere humans! Um, duh – what do they think they are? They come here full of all of their own human wisdom and teaching and tradition, all the while telling us that we should NOT have anything to do with human wisdom and teaching and tradition.

They of course cannot be reasoned with, because it seems they think reason, rationality and common sense are all of the devil. They seem to think the more irrational and foolish they are, the more godly they are. Never mind all the biblical injunctions to think and use our minds for the glory of God.

I was just reading again today in Scripture where James insists that we be wise – and he defines godly wisdom in these terms: “But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, open to reason, full of mercy and good fruits, impartial and sincere” (James 3:17, ESV).

Hmm, “open to reason”! Yes God wants us to be reasonable. He wants us to think straight. He wants us to use the minds he has given us for his glory. He does NOT delight in stupidity, deliberate ignorance, and intellectual laziness. Instead we are to love God with ALL of our minds. Why do some believers have such a hard time getting this!?

But these folks will latch onto a few texts, twist them out of context, and somehow think they have made their case. For example, they will mention Paul’s words about being regarded as a fool for Christ’s sake. But they really should realise that Scripture refers to at least two types of fools – one in a positive sense and one in a negative sense.

The Bible warns constantly about fools who have no knowledge and no wisdom. We are to avoid such fools at all costs. Proverbs especially speaks to this. But Paul is NOT saying he is – and we should be – that sort of fool. What he is saying is that as he follows Christ, the unbelieving world will consider him to be a fool.

Paul does not care what the world thinks of him. He is happy to be regarded as a fool if he must. But that does not mean he was foolish, or a fool in the sense warned against in Scripture. Indeed, we know that Paul was incredibly intelligent and well educated.

As such he sought to be all things to all men. To the unlearned and uneducated he could easily present the gospel and biblical truth. But he could also readily mingle and interact with philosophers and other intelligent folks, as in Athens. Paul did not throw his brain away, but he used it for Christ and the Kingdom.

Let me finish with a few obvious Christian truths here:

-Can a Christian have plenty of head knowledge but little in the heart? Yes
-Can a Christian have plenty of heart knowledge but little in the head? Yes
-Can a person become proud and arrogant and unspiritual with all the knowledge and learning they have? Yes.
-Can a person become proud and arrogant and unspiritual with the little or no knowledge and learning they have? Yes.
-Are there some learned and educated folks who look down on and despise less learned and educated folks? Yes.
-Are there some unlearned and uneducated folks who look down on and despise more learned and educated folks? Yes.

Both extremes are wrong and both are to be rejected. People in both camps can be just as carnal and proud and fleshly as those in the other camps. Both sorts of believers need to repent of these sins, stop judging those in the other camp, and start becoming a bit more Christlike.

Glory in human reason alone is no good, but so too is glorying in how stupid or uninformed you are. Neither one brings glory to God nor advances the cause of Christ. I want little to do with either group of Christians to be honest. Both can be just so pompous, arrogant and fleshly.

[1351 words]

7 Replies to “The Greatest Commandment – The Most Violated Commandment”

  1. Amen!

    So many people don’t understand that God made us all different for a very good reason. We all have our own talents and the limited, physical nature of things in this world means that if you excel in one area you are likely to perform poorly in another area.

    Just as in marriage there is a synergy between a husband and wife, because they are not the same, so it is in the church.

    1Co 12:14 For the body is not one member, but many.
    1Co 12:15 If the foot shall say, Because I am not the hand, I am not of the body; is it therefore not of the body?
    1Co 12:16 And if the ear shall say, Because I am not the eye, I am not of the body; is it therefore not of the body?
    1Co 12:17 If all the body were an eye, where would be the hearing? If all hearing, where would be the smelling?
    1Co 12:18 But now God has set the members, each one of them, in the body as it has pleased Him.
    1Co 12:19 And if they were all one member, where would be the body?
    1Co 12:20 But now indeed many are the members, yet only one body.
    1Co 12:21 And the eye cannot say to the hand, I have no need of you; nor again the head to the feet, I have no need of you.
    1Co 12:22 But much rather the members of the body seeming to be weaker are necessary.
    1Co 12:23 And those members of the body which we think to be less honorable, on these we put more abundant honor around them. And our unpresentable members have more abundant propriety.
    1Co 12:24 For our presentable members have no need, but God tempered the body together, giving more abundant honor to the member having need;
    1Co 12:25 that there not be division in the body, but that the members should have the same care for one another.
    1Co 12:26 And if one member suffers, all the members suffer with it; if one member is glorified, all the members rejoice with it.
    1Co 12:27 And you are the body of Christ, and members in part.

  2. Hi Bill, I’m so sorry that you have to constantly have to put up with a bunch of clueless detractors. I would like to share a very small part of my personal testimony as to why I worship and love God with every part of my being; Just over 40 years ago at around 2:00am on a Sunday morning, I was by myself standing on a dark, empty, factory floor. In the very depths of my depression at that time, I was actively planning to take myself and my small truck, and wrap ourselves around the nearest big tree I could find! It was then that The God of the Universe, The Lord Jesus Christ, took time out from His busy schedule to personally visit me. From 2:00am until dawn, I poured my heart out to Him, and He in turn showered me with His love. Bill, I can never forget what Jesus Christ did for me all those years ago, and that is why I continue to love Him and serve Him to this very day, with EVERY PART of my being including my mind!! Bill, I’m sorry if I went a bit off target in my response. I would like to think, that for “every” detractor you have to put up with, that, there are at least a couple of hundred of the rest of us actively encouraging you, and upholding you in prayer. Bless you heaps, Kel.

  3. Excellent article, Bill. So glad to see you have been addressing these issues in your last few articles. It is when we let Reason and critical thinking depart that the lunacy we see in today’s culture starts to increase. If Christians are not able to intelligently address these issues, they will be greatly hindered in helping the tide to turn. Many in our culture do not accept the Bible as the Word of God, so if Christians limit their approach to simply quoting the Bible, they will continue to be dismissed as holding on to a worldview countless thousands are unable to take seriously. How would this bring glory to God?

  4. Great article Bill. In the words of G.K. Chesterton, “Theology is simply that part of religion that requires brains.”

    As we know, bad theology leads to bad philosophy. And bad philosophy leads to Hell.

  5. As a latecomer to your commentaries, your title intrigued me as the Greatest Commandment is not only violated but IMHO abused. Permit me to share in hope of correction, refinement or guidance.

    Part 1: Love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind. This is the greatest and most important commandment.
    Part 2: The second is like it:
    Part 2a: Love your neighbor
    Part 2b: as yourself.
    Part 3 All the Law and the Prophets depend on these two commandments.

    The secular trinity is comprised of “me, myself and I”, Part 2B to the exclusion of Part 1 and to a lesser extent 2A except to serve the interests of their self-interests.

    I contend that if one does not embrace Part 1 as the greatest and most important commandment, Part 2 is impossible while Part 3: clarifies breath and depth of the cultural divide.

    If charity can be defined as “Love in Action” with love being defined as desiring the best for our God, our neighbor and ourself with whom we share our 3Ts, Time, Talent & Treasure as we know “God loves a charitable giver” to enable us to address the “problem of pain” in the world. I would also suggest that our time is more important than our talent and talent more important than treasure without diminishing the value of each.

    This though evolved because I could not find a short elevator speech or executive summary addressing the “problem of pain” that perhaps is the single and only issue that bridges the cultural divide; with God all things are possible, without God all things are permissible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: