Bill Muehlenberg's commentary on issues of the day...

Apostates Promoting Diabolical Agendas

Oct 30, 2020

The apostates are becoming ever bolder – and dangerous:

Here’s the scoop: Apostasy is a real thing. So are apostates. They exist, they are dangerous, and they are deadly. There is also a predictable track they will follow: first they deny some basics of the Christian faith; then they will promote some clearly anti-Christian agenda items; and finally they will fully turn against the faith as they hate on believers.

We see this happening all too often in church history. And one such person I have sadly had to write about over the years is a good case in point. I refer to the former English evangelical leader Steve Chalke. For years now he has denied or rubbished key Christian teachings, and on top of that, he has been pushing things like homosexuality. And now he is using his radicalism to go after biblical Christians.

The progression – or regression – is just what we would expect when people say no to Christ and Scripture and side with the secular left and its crusades. And the shocking thing is so many Christians are quite clueless about all this. Indeed, once when I was speaking interstate, I learned that my home church actually had him there as the main speaker! I quickly notified the head pastor about his dubious Christian credentials.

His aberrant views on the atonement for example had been quite well known for some time. As I wrote in a 2009 piece, his views are certainly at odds with historic Christianity. As I said then: “Consider English emergent church leader Steve Chalke, who was recently here in Australia. He is renowned for his 2004 book, The Lost Message of Jesus, in which he strongly condemned the penal, substitutionary understanding of the atonement, regarding it as ‘cosmic child abuse’.”

Of course simply being a key player in the trendy emerging church movement should have set warning bells off. I have written a number of pieces looking at how very harmful and deceptive this outfit is. See here for example:

Hot on the heels of his rejection of orthodox biblical teaching on the work of Christ at Calvary, he jumped on board the radical homosexual bandwagon. In a 2013 piece I said this about Chalke and his emergent buddies who were embracing the radical homosexual agenda:

The Word of God is not all that important to the emergents, and we cannot even know whether it is true anyway. So let’s just concentrate on getting along, being really inclusive and tolerant, and accepting everyone just as they are. Let’s forget about all this ‘sin’ nonsense and let’s just focus on being really nice and accepting of everyone and everything.

So Chalke, like so many other theological revisionists who no longer embrace the Bible, have simply made things up as they go along. After all, if the Word of God is not authoritative and conclusive on important moral issues, then we just wing it.

But being in favour of what the Bible is not in favour of usually is not the end of things for these apostates. Soon enough they actually turn against Christians and Christianity, and actually support the persecution of them. And that is just what we find Chalke now up to: he is supporting cracking down on churches that fail to push the homosexual agenda.

As one article says about this:

Former evangelical Steve Chalke has claimed that churches could soon face prosecution over their treatment of LGBT people.  He tweeted over the weekend: “When I began to welcome LGBT people into my church, the Evangelicals threw the charity I founded out of their alliance. But I believe what amounts to the abuse of LGBT people by churches is likely to soon see a crop of high-profile prosecutions.” 

His tweet was in reference to the Evangelical Alliance, which in 2014 discontinued membership of the Oasis Trust, the charity founded by Chalke, after he came out in support of same-sex relationships. Since announcing his change of view on sexuality, Chalke has become an outspoken advocate for LGBT people. 

Chalke made his latest comments ahead of a conference he was hosting on Saturday about creating “safe” churches for LGBT people. The conference was endorsed by Sir Elton John, who said: “The failure of many churches to welcome, accept and include LGBTQ+ people creates stigma, loneliness, fear and denial, causing lasting damage to their wellbeing and mental health.”

Chalke suggested that even offering pastoral concern or prayer could constitute psychological abuse. “Ultimately every church ought to want to provide sanctuary and safety for all, especially for those who have experienced hurt, rejection or marginalisation,” he said. 

“While the debate about how to read the Bible in relation to LGBT+ people continues, the absence of safe and affirming churches has had a significant, negative and sometimes tragic impact on LGBT+ people, as well as on their families and friends.

“What churches often describe as pastoral concern, prayer or even ‘deliverance ministry’ for those with ‘same-sex attraction’ is, in fact, a highly toxic and psychologically abusive environment where vulnerable LGBT+ people, many of them teenagers or even children, report that they have been taught to believe that their desires are ‘sinful’.” In additional comments to the Guardian, Chalke said that the practices of many churches “amount to serious and sustained abuse”.  

Of course this is becoming quite common all throughout the West. Simply sharing what the Bible teaches about human sexuality is now considered to be “hate speech” and something that must be cracked down on. And offering counsel for those who seek help for their unwanted sexual attractions is being outlawed in many places.

It is the same old slide down the tubes: First, an immoral behaviour or lifestyle is permitted. Then it is heavily promoted. And finally, those who dare to resist all this are persecuted. Sinful actions and behaviours become the new norm, and they also become mandatory.

And the apostates are fully happy to see all this come about. They first reject their own faith. They then embrace serious theological error as well as immoral practices and lifestyles. And then they demand that all Christians do the same – or else.

Apostasy is serious stuff. It of course has serious eternal consequences for the apostate, but it also does great harm to so many others. All the more reason why Christians must stand firm and stay firm. They must work at their faith and actively seek to resist that which would lead them away from biblical belief and behaviour.

Let me close with three important quotes on apostasy. The first is from C. S. Lewis in his classic book, Mere Christianity:

Now Faith, in the sense in which I am here using the word, is the art of holding on to things your reason has once accepted, in spite of your changing moods. For moods will change, whatever view your reason takes…. Consequently one must train the habit of Faith. . . . The first step is to recognise the fact that your moods change. The next is to make sure that, if you have once accepted Christianity, then some of its main doctrines shall be deliberately held before your mind for some time every day. That is why daily prayers and religious readings and churchgoing are necessary parts of the Christian life. We have to be continually reminded of what we believe. Neither this belief nor any other will automatically remain alive in the mind. It must be fed. And as a matter of fact, if you examined a hundred people who had lost their faith in Christianity, I wonder how many of them would turn out to have been reasoned out of it by honest argument? Do not most people simply drift away?

And this from North American theologian and New Testament scholar D. A. Carson from For the Love of God, vol. 2:

People do not drift toward Holiness. Apart from grace-driven effort, people do not gravitate toward godliness, prayer, obedience to Scripture, faith, and delight in the Lord. We drift toward compromise and call it tolerance; we drift toward disobedience and call it freedom; we drift toward superstition and call it faith. We cherish the indiscipline of lost self-control and call it relaxation; we slouch toward prayerlessness and delude ourselves into thinking we have escaped legalism; we slide toward godlessness and convince ourselves we have been liberated. 

Lastly, these words of warning from the Apostle Paul as found in Acts 20: 29-3: “I know that after I leave, savage wolves will come in among you and will not spare the flock. Even from your own number men will arise and distort the truth in order to draw away disciples after them. So be on your guard!”

[1451 words]

7 Responses to Apostates Promoting Diabolical Agendas

  • Spot on. You can now have an understanding as to just how corrupt Sodom and Gomorrah must have been for our Lord to destroy it. It starts with same sex than advances to any sort of immoral sexual behavior. It is like a virus that breaks out into different strands eventually contaminating everyone. It got so bad in Sodom and Gomorrah that the infected wanted to enter into Angelic beings. So it does not surprise me that evil spirit wants to put its tentacles into our churches and contaminate us as well.

  • Thanks Bill for your ongoing battle in the culture wars. This is so disheartening since these people often have a charisma that enabled them to build congregations but now enables them like the Pied Piper to draw people off to destruction : people who haven’t got their lives firmly rooted in the Word of God. Without being anchored and rooted in the Word, these people are not going to be able to weather the huge storms that are ahead and may find themselves confused and no longer able to discern truth. I pray that we will be able to rescue these souls by speaking truth and praying for them.

  • It starts with believing long-age evolution. Genesis 1 as history is the litmus test to be applied. If they don’t believe it, discard them. They are headed off the rails already.

  • Bill,
    I think Paul’s warning is so appropriate, apostacy is not only in the past but so very much in the present. I take comfort in his further words, vs 31 and 32:
    Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn everyone night and day with tears.
    And now brethren, I commend you to God, and to the word of his grace, which is able to build you up, and to give you an inheritance among all them which are sanctified.
    We must denounce all errors and warn our ‘neighbors’, apostasy is insidious and damning. Be warned, be armed, be vigilant and be vocal, and this with kindness because so many are mislead and will not respond to criticism.

  • Dear Bill,
    This so accurately describes the loss of our “Spiritual parents” who led us to Christ. 42 years of walking with the Lord, just in the time we knew them, and then someone whispered in their ear, “Did God really say….”. Our hearts are broken, but I know we are not alone in this kind of loss, as you have have highlighted here.
    I know that God is patient, but he does occasionally ‘shake the tree’ and the time of shaking is coming.

    As always, thank you.
    Ron Adams

  • “Sinful actions and behaviours become the new norm, and they also become mandatory.”

    This is worrisome how long till simply refusing the advances of a homosexual or refusing to sleep with him will be considered homophobic and hateful??? ‘Let him make love to you or go to jail’.

    The descent often starts with one compromise we convince ourselves it is a small matter a small compromise but as the saying goes “if you open that door even once you’ll never shut it again”!! Each new compromise is easier than the last till it becomes so easy you truly don’t believe in anything you go what ever way the wind is blowing. “Rudderless and lost in a sea of ecclesiastical possibilities”

Leave a Reply