Remembering the Armenians
One hundred years ago a horrific massacre of non-Muslim minorities was launched by Ottoman Turks. More specifically, on April 24 1915, the Ottoman authorities began their program of mass annihilation of the largely Christian Armenian, Assyrian and Greek populations.
It took place over several decades and witnessed the wholesale persecution, torture, rape and murder of at least one and a half million Armenians and others. Barnabas Fund, which works on behalf of the persecuted church, offers this overview:
In 1900 Christians constituted around 32% of Ottoman Turkey’s population. Just 27 years later the figure was down to about 1.8%. In early 1915, a fatwa was issued against non-Muslims in the Ottoman Empire. Muslims were called to fight the Christian minorities with whom they had been living as neighbours, albeit not on equal or necessarily peaceful terms. Many refused to take part, but those who did inflicted colossal suffering and destruction on the Armenian, Greek and Assyrian Christians.
It is thought that over 1.5 million Armenians, up to 750,000 Assyrians and up to 1.5 million Greeks – men, women and children – were killed in the state-sanctioned genocide over a 30-year period; yet their tragic loss is barely remembered today. The Armenians’ Golgotha and the Assyrians’ Seyfo (“sword”) is a forgotten genocide against forgotten peoples….
Though many Armenians fought for the Empire in the First World War, the government chose to systematically disarm and kill Armenian soldiers. Some were murdered in public squares or by using the Islamic method for slaughtering animals: tied-up, put on their backs and throats slit. On 24 April 1915 authorities arrested and later executed Armenian intellectuals and leaders.
Christians were freighted by train or forced to walk hundreds of miles without provisions to concentration camps in the Syrian Desert for “manual labour”. Only one quarter of all deportees survived the exposure, starvation, violent attacks and other abuses to reach their destinations, whereupon many were murdered in organised killings. Those who tried to protect Armenians often met the same end. Killing units in Deir al-Zor smashed children against rocks, mutilated adults with swords, and burned people alive. Some 200,000 Armenians converted to Islam in order to be spared. In 1915 alone, approximately 800,000 Armenians were killed.
To make all this more real, more graphic, consider the accompanying photo of a Turkish official tormenting starving Armenian children by showing them a piece of bread during this genocide.
Let me offer two accounts from those who had forebears involved in all this hellishness. The first is Stella Morabito who is the granddaughter of genocide survivors. She writes:
About 1.5 million Armenian Christians were systematically slaughtered by the government of the Ottoman Empire. It was jumpstarted on April 24, 1915, when hundreds of Armenian community leaders and intellectuals were rounded up in Constantinople, arrested, and killed.
Young Armenian women who were not raped and killed could end up Islamified and taken in as wives or concubines.
The goal was to exterminate every Armenian Christian, whether child, woman, or man. The killings themselves often included all manner of butchery, torture, and humiliation. My grandmother lamented the crucifixion of her father, who was known in the village as a holy man.
Another part of this extermination program involved deportations that forced Armenians out of their homes and basically put them on death marches into the Syrian Desert. Many died of starvation and exhaustion on these caravans. Others succumbed to diseases like typhus in lice-infested camp conditions. Young Armenian women who were not raped and killed could end up Islamified and taken in as wives or concubines. My grandmother’s younger sister was taken into a harem.
Some of the most harrowing accounts of the murders are included in the extraordinary memoirs of the survivor Bishop Grigoris Balakian, entitled “Armenian Golgotha.”
And David Kupelian recounts the story of his grandparents:
It was 100 years ago, and my dad, just a toddler then, along with his mother and baby sister were among thousands of Armenian Christians being herded into the Syrian Der Zor desert east of Aleppo to die. That’s right, to die. Forced into such a miserable and dangerous trek, the plan was that exposure, hunger, thirst, bandits or marauding soldiers would get the job done, one way or the other. As for my father’s father, a physician, he had already been forced into the Turkish army against his will to head a medical regiment to tend to the Turkish soldiers’ injuries.
“One of my earliest recollections, I was not quite three years old at the time,” my dad told me shortly before he died in 1988, was that “the wagon we were in had tipped over, my hand was broken and bloody, and mother was looking for my infant sister who had rolled away. The next thing I remember after that, mother was on a horse, holding my baby sister, and had me sitting behind her, saying, ‘Hold on tight, or the Turks will get you!’”…
In 1909, my great-grandfather, a Protestant minister named Steelianos Leondiades, was traveling to the major Turkish city of Adana to attend a pastors’ conference. Today, Incirlik Air Base, used by the U.S. Air Force, is five miles east of Adana. But then, under the Ottoman caliph, Abdul-Hamid II, ethnic cleansing was the order of the day. Here’s how my maternal grandmother, Anna Paulson, daughter of Steelianos, told the story:
“Some of the Turkish officers came to the conference room and told all these ministers – there were 70 of them, ministers and laymen and a few wives: ‘If you embrace the Islamic religion you will all be saved. If you don’t, you will all be killed.’”
My great-grandfather, acting as a spokesman for the ministers’ group, asked the Turks for 15 minutes so they could make their decision, according to my grandmother’s account. During that time the ministers and their companions talked, read the Bible to each other, and prayed. In the end, none of them would renounce their Christian faith and convert to Islam.
“And then,” Anna recalled, “they were all killed. They were not even buried. They were all thrown down the ravine.”
The only reason we know any details of this particular massacre, she said, is that one victim survived the ordeal.
“One man woke up; he wasn’t dead,” my grandmother said. “He woke up and got up and said, ‘Brethren, brethren, is there anybody alive here? I’m alive, come on, let’s go out together.’”
Ultimately, by the grace of God, both sides of my family made it to the Promised Land – America – and eventually my father met and married my mother, and that’s how my brother, sister and I were blessed to come on the scene.
But plenty of leaders past and present – leaders like Obama – are seeking to whitewash all this. Morabito concludes her piece this way:
In the end, the Ottoman government really believed its problems could be solved only by brute force and the killing of innocents. Perhaps even more importantly, it happened because they expected to get away with it. This is key. If we corrupt the language so that we do not acknowledge genocide when it happens – as President Obama just did – then we feed into the expectations of all potential perpetrators that they can easily get away with murder. So we are liable to see genocide and other forms of mass slaughter repeated. No true civilization can afford to falsify the historical record or corrupt the language.
Inscribed on one of the walls of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum is a stark lesson in this. It is a statement by Adolph Hitler, who rationalized mass slaughter and expected people simply to avert their eyes and forget: “Who, after all, today speaks of the annihilation of the Armenians?”
And Kupelian reminds us of the ongoing significance of all this:
Today we have ISIS, which Barack Obama infamously sized up as the “jayvee team” a few months before it blitzkrieged its way across large parts of the Middle East. ISIS is, in fact, now frequently compared to the Hitler machine of the early 1930s, maniacal and growing, but not yet a massive world power with fearsome weapons.
And just to bring things full circle, consider the primary role model for ISIS. No, it’s not Hitler, even though ISIS and Hitler share an infinite hatred for Jews. Rather, ISIS is emulating the world’s previous Sunni Islamic caliphate – namely, the Turkish Ottoman Empire, whose martyrdom of 1.5 million Armenian Christians is being remembered today.
This was a Holocaust we must never forget. Indeed, it is being repeated right before our very eyes with countless Christians being massacred by the political ideology known as Islam. When will we wake up? When will we respond? Or is this all another sad case of history repeating itself?
14 Replies to “Remembering the Armenians”
Given half a chance, I think today’s Turkey will take up the mantle and finish what the Ottoman’s of old started.
Agree with that Simon. And still leaders in the West are blinkered. I saw Boris the Red, who is shaping as a major player in the up-coming British elections, telling the voters on television that all of this islamic violence has nothing to do with islam.
I never knew the extent of the genocide. The following essay by Australian Professor Robert Manne is very interesting.
Australian lawyer Geoffrey Robertson wrote An Inconvenient Genocide detailing the reasons he considers the Turkish elimination of the Armenians a crime against humanity, a genocide.
I agree with Simon. It seems that they will do or say anything to further the cause of Islam. Can we therefore trust anything they say. People who know one or two Muslims say they are lovely folk, & it seems they are, as long as they don’t get together in large groups. Then the mob culture seems to take over. I’ve had Emails claiming that many Muslims in North Africa are turning to Christianity. Is that true? Will Islam prevail???
Thanks Bill. We need to pressure the Turkish government to (i) admit the genocide (which so far they have refused to do); (ii) make reparations to the Armenians; and (iii) vow never to perpetrate the same thing again, especially with Erdogan making noises about a resumption.
We need to pressure our own government to put pressure in turn on Turkey to do as above.
BTW, I drew attention to this matter at the time of the centenary of the beginning of the genocide, 24th April – over a week ago:
I received one comment at the time, and no more. Is no-one else interested? Lest we Forget!!
Today’s genocide is yesterday’s unfinished business – see http://rlprayerbulletin.blogspot.com.au/2015/04/rlpb-306-genocide-then-and-now.html
And this is why Germany can accept responsibility but Turkey can’t: http://rlprayerbulletin.blogspot.com.au/2015/04/rlpb-307-april-update-incl-syria.html
The Turkish massacres were and are gobsmacking.
What’s so chilling is that the Turks won’t even own it.
That actually seems psychopathically cold, if Turkey was a person.
You’re glad you did it, so celebrate,
You’re ashamed you did it, so apologise and repent.
The blatant denial is something that a psychopath or narcissist might do….
What’s also interesting to me is the Shia and Sunni split.
The Islamic world comes across as “Arab” yet 3 major players in it are not, and these major players are aware of their “non-Arabness”. Turkey, Egypt and Iran.
The civil war in Yemen has been a shadow war between the Saudis and Iran. All is not well in the house of Islam….
I can see the Turks pushing to regain their position as the leaders of the Caliphate.
I also imagine they weren’t too happy that the Arabs sided with the British in WWI and rebelled.
The Ottoman Turks offered the opportunity for Christians to become Muslims, as per Islamic teaching. However, these converts to Islam weren’t seen as true Muslims and were only allowed to grow a moustache, instead of a full beard.
Also they weren’t seen as real Ottomans, and were slaughtered when it suited the Turks.
Such was the fate of the Janissary Corps.
As a side note, Turkey has the largest armed force in NATO, after the USA….
Islamist pressure grows in Turkey….
It will be interesting to see Turkey’s role in the coming years.
And perhaps not in a good way….
Excellent links, Elizabeth Kendal ?
I’m riled… but not sure which riles me the most:
That picture of the Turk teasing starving children, or any Christian voting for Obama – twice.
Just like Israel, Armenia stands, demonstrating the impotence of Islam to conquer truth. (I have the privilege of knowing some who were connected to the inspiring martyr Haik Hovsepian).
Now if only the west could do some standing, even a little bit would be nice.
Excellent Bill. Well may we say Lest We Forget because we never remember! A craven PM and Foreign Minister both kow-tow to Turkey. The murders of countless Christians has again started and gutless Western appeasers say, and do, nothing for fear of offending the murderous savages.
Who will ride with them? Certainly not the ‘twitterers’ who salve their consciences with glib one-liners, in phoney feel-good, campaigns in Australia.
Poor Fellow My Country….indeed (with apologies to Xavier Herbert)
Bill, I appreciate your blog so much. As you are so prolific a writer, I confess it’s sometimes hard to keep up with everything you post. And I only discovered you of late, so I have much catching up to do.
I first heard of the genocide of the Armenians while reading the bio of Demos Shakarian, founder of the Full Gospel Businessmen’s Association. So I asked my Mom about it because she’s a world history buff. She filled me in on the attempted genocide of the Armenian people by the Ottoman Turks. This was never addressed in my high school World History class. Until now, I’ve not a word of it, aside from Mr. Shakarian and my mother. Thanks to you, Bill, the word is going forth. This is a vey good work you do here with your blog. It is much appreciated.
Many thanks indeed Vicki. And hey, I can’t keep up with everything I post either!
Apologies Murray Adamthwaite, I missed your early alert about the Armenian Genocide although I was already onto it, having purchased Geoffrey Robertson’s book ‘Inconvenient Genocide’ mentioned above by Jo Deller.
So, wanting to make a practical demonstration of solidarity with the Armenian community on the 100th anniversary of the beginning of the genocide, my wife and I attended the Armenian Genocide Commemoration event at Sydney Town Hall on 24th April, despite the fact that we are not Armenian and that some of the program was in the Armenian language!
So yes Murray, I too am interested and thank you and Bill for drawing attention to the barbaric persecution of Greek, Assyrian and especially Armenian Christians in the final years of the Ottoman Empire. Lest we forget.
I am with you Vicky – the same book taught me about what I had never heard of and I went to school in Germany where we didn’t hear of it either, or at least I don’t remember. Another book I found since then is “A Bride’s Escape”, not sure who the author is now. It is a biography of an Armenean girl who went to america just before the official genocide, though the precursors were already well visible.